Real Estate SystemsRecruitmentTeam Building

Why Fresh Talent Outperforms Experienced Agents

Real estate principals who hire based on experience alone are missing out on top performers. Our data shows agents with less than 2 years experience, when properly trained, significantly outperform seasoned agents within 18 months. Here’s the systematic approach that’s transforming recruitment in real estate agencies across Australia.

28 July 2025
Why Fresh Talent Outperforms Experienced Agents

There’s a persistent myth in real estate that’s costing principals their best talent: the belief that you should always hire experienced agents.

But here’s what the data actually tells us.

The Shocking Truth About "Experienced" Agents

Some of the worst performing team members I see in most businesses come with the most impressive resumes. That’s not an opinion – that’s cold, hard data from tracking performance across the agencies I coach.

When we analysed the numbers, we discovered something that challenges everything most principals believe about recruitment:

Agents with less than two years experience who underwent structured training dramatically outperform experienced agents within an eighteen month period.

Let that sink in for a moment.

Why Experience Can Actually Work Against You

Experienced agents often bring three major roadblocks to your business:

  1. Baggage from previous agencies
  2. Entrenched bad habits that are hard to break
  3. Resistance to systems – the classic “I’ve always done it this way” syndrome

Meanwhile, fresh talent brings exactly what high-performing agencies need:

The Three-Step System That Changes Everything

You can’t just hire anyone, though. You need a systematic recruitment approach focused on potential, not just past performance.

Inside our program, we use a three-step process that’s revolutionising how real estate principals build their teams:

Step 1: Behavioural Profiling to Identify Natural Sales Traits

Instead of relying on gut feel, we use proven profiling techniques to identify candidates who naturally possess the traits that lead to real estate success.

Step 2: Commitment Testing Through Multiple Stage Interviews

This isn’t about making the process harder – it’s about ensuring you’re hiring people who want a career, not just a job.

Step 3: Structured Eighteen Month Development Pathway

Fresh talent needs structure. We provide a clear roadmap that takes new agents from zero to high-performer in 18 months.

The Results Speak for Themselves

When we implement these systems into our clients’ businesses, the transformation is dramatic:

  • Retention rates soar
  • Per agent productivity more than doubles

Your Next Move

Stop chasing resumes and start building talent.

The agencies that embrace this approach are creating unstoppable teams whilst their competitors are stuck in the endless cycle of recruiting experienced agents who underperform and leave.

Related

Back to news
Why Fresh Talent Outperforms Experienced Agents
Real Estate SystemsRecruitmentTeam Building

Why Fresh Talent Outperforms Experienced Agents

Breaking Real Estate Agency Growth Ceilings
Business StrategyLeadershipReal Estate Systems

Breaking Real Estate Agency Growth Ceilings

Why 50% of New Agents Quit
Agent DevelopmentBusiness SystemsLeadership

Why 50% of New Agents Quit

Get started

Jess works with business leaders to achieve peak performance through implementing effective systems and processes to both nurture teams and scale businesses.

Jess works with business leaders to achieve peak performance, nurturing teams and scale businesses.